“You want to find one of us who chooses to be out here without a past, I’d bloody pay to see that”

Evie Wyld, All the Birds, Singing (2013)

As a way of setting out a novel’s stall, this opening sentence works rather well:

Another sheep, mangled and bled out, her innards not yet crusting and the vapours rising from her like a steamed pudding.

The novel this introduces will be unsentimental about the harsh realities of its protagonist’s life; and full of smells and other sensations, often unpleasant ones. But then there’s that image of the steamed pudding, a seemingly incongruous reference to home comforts; a suggestion, perhaps, that even this life of blood and death has its positive points for the individual who’s living it.

That individual is Jake Whyte, a woman whom we first meet living on an island somewhere off the British coast, with no company but her dog and flock of sheep. We then step into Jake’s past in Australia, where we find her working on a sheep station having clearly left somewhere in a hurry; when one of Jake’s colleagues threatens to reveal her secret unless she sleeps with him, she punches him hard enough to break his jaw – and that is the latest event we’ll see of Jake’s Australian life, because the rest of that narrative strand goes backwards chronologically.

As in her debut, After the Fire, a Still Small Voice, Evie Wyld works with two parallel narratives which remain separate but nevertheless reflect and illuminate each other – and not simply because (as in this case) they chronicle stages in the same character’s life. Wyld highlights the contrasts and similarities between the environments in which Jake finds herself: she’s looking after sheep in both, and doing so is (to an extent) a means for her to escape the past. But the sheep station is a very different place from the island: life in the former, with its workers arriving from all over, is transitory; the latter feels much more like Jake’s attempt to build a permanent life for herself. That impression is underlined by the use of different tenses: Jake’s narration on the island is in the past tense, while her flashbacks are in the present tense – so the chronological present feels more stable than what (for Jake) has already happened.

Mysteries power both narratives in All the Birds, Singing. The mystery of the flashbacks is, of course, how Jake got to where she ended, and the nature of the secrets in her past. Wyld constructs this very well indeed, revealing just enough information to maintain the tension (there’s more than one revelation to be had about Jake’s history), and allowing the past to bleed into the present in ways that enrich both.

On the island, the mystery is a matter of concern for Jake: something is killing her sheep – maybe a wild animal, maybe something more human. I think there’s a clear metaphor at play here: Jake’s flock is her protection, the stability of her life; anything that threatens the sheep is then threatening the equilibrium of her life. The story of this plot strand is, for me, the story of how Jake finds a place among the community of people on the island, rather than just living by herself. Jake befriends a man named Lloyd, which allows her to build a relationship from first principles, as it were; after we’ve seen Jake verbally outmanoeuvred in a few conversations with islanders early on, there’s a strong note of optimism to her thought about Lloyd: “He doesn’t know me.

The ending of All the Birds, Singing (perhaps I should say ‘endings’ because of the two strands,  but I still think of the ending as a complete ‘unit’) takes a turn into an unexpected place, and for me it works perfectly – it shows how far Jake has come, balanced with a bitter note of irony. It puts the cap on another fine piece of work by Evie Wyld.

Some other reviews of All the Birds, Singing: Savidge Reads; Fran Slater for Bookmunch; …but books are better.


  1. I have this and I’m looking forward to it, more so having read your review. Nicely picked up on with the use of the tenses and the reflection of the emotional rather than merely temporal place.

  2. Thanks for the review, David – I think you’ve captured the book very well, and as you say it’s thoughtfully and carefully written. (In fact, I appreciated how quiet its style was – a lot of literary fiction shouts its quality, but Wyld is content to write so well you cease to notice her trying.)

    I wonder, though, if you felt like me that it was at times a little too neat? The symbolism and allegories, the parallel narratives, the misery and mystery memoir elements resolving within each other … It’s all really elegant, but there’s almost too little friction between the various elements. There’s still plenty of grit, of course – as you say, Wyld gets a lot of worthy mileage out of making natures of all kinds ugly – but somehow I wanted it to go down just a little less easily.

    I’m griping, aren’t I?

  3. David Hebblethwaite

    24th August 2013 at 6:36 pm

    Max: Hope you enjoy it!

    Dan: Good to hear you liked the book (and the review – thanks!)

    I appreciated how quiet its style was

    Then you’d probably also enjoy After the Fire, a Still Small Voice, whose quietness is a real strength.

    I wonder, though, if you felt like me that it was at times a little too neat? The symbolism and allegories, the parallel narratives, the misery and mystery memoir elements resolving within each other…

    Hmm, possibly. But I like that sort of quality in a novel, so it’s a plus point for me.

    I’m griping, aren’t I?

    Yes. 🙂

  4. Hmm, possibly. But I like that sort of quality in a novel, so it’s a plus point for me.

    Usually, so do I – I like that feeling of unity (a quality many distrust in me). Hm, I wonder if I read pat-ness where there wasn’t any? Might try to write my own piece to think things through.

    Yes. 🙂

    That’s me told! 😉

  5. Thanks for including a link to my review, I only just noticed. Great book, and I enjoyed your review.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

© 2024 David's Book World

Theme by Anders NorénUp ↑